Two new books explore the history and impact of cancel culture on comedy, challenging the notion that it’s harder to be funny today.
In the age of cancel culture and heightened sensitivities, comedians have often lamented the challenges of crafting jokes that won’t offend. However, two recently published books, “Outrageous: A History of Showbiz and the Culture Wars” by Kliph Nesteroff and “Comedy Book: How Comedy Conquered Culture — and the Magic That Makes It Work” by Jesse David Fox, offer a fresh perspective on the subject. These books delve into the history of comedy and showbiz, revealing that the struggle between comedians and societal norms is not a new phenomenon. By examining the past, they shed light on the resilience and adaptability of comedy in the face of changing cultural landscapes.
1: A Perpetual State of Despair
Nesteroff’s “Outrageous” takes readers on a journey through the annals of showbiz, uncovering a recurring pattern of entertainers grappling with the censorious climate of their time. From Steve Allen’s complaints about the “very touchy times” in 1955 to Jerry Seinfeld’s warnings about college audiences’ sensitivities in 2015, the book highlights the enduring nature of this struggle. Nesteroff argues that while social media may amplify the perception of heightened sensitivity, historical evidence reveals that entertainers have always faced similar challenges, as demonstrated by vintage letters to the editor.
2: Embracing Risk and Backlash
In “Comedy Book,” Fox approaches the issue from a different angle, emphasizing that the risk of backlash is an inherent part of comedy. He suggests that political correctness, while making comedy more challenging, also adds excitement to the craft. Fox compares it to a football game where the difficulty of running with the ball adds thrill and satisfaction to scoring a touchdown. By reframing the narrative, Fox encourages comedians to embrace the constraints and find creative ways to navigate the evolving cultural landscape.
3: The Evolution of Comedy
Both books emphasize the adaptability of comedy throughout history. Nesteroff’s research reveals that comedy has always evolved alongside societal changes, finding new ways to push boundaries and challenge norms. From vaudeville to the comedy boom of the 1980s and the rise of alternative comedy, comedians have consistently found innovative ways to connect with audiences while addressing the issues of their time. Fox’s “Comedy Book” further explores the magic behind comedy, dissecting the techniques and strategies that make jokes work and analyzing how comedians have adapted their craft to suit changing cultural norms.
4: The Power of Comedy
Despite the challenges, comedy remains a powerful force in shaping culture. Both authors highlight the ability of comedy to challenge authority, provoke thought, and provide much-needed relief in difficult times. By examining the history of comedy, Nesteroff and Fox demonstrate that it has always been a catalyst for change and a reflection of society’s values. From Lenny Bruce’s groundbreaking social commentary to the satirical brilliance of Jon Stewart, comedy has the power to push boundaries, spark conversations, and bring people together.
Conclusion:
In an era where cancel culture and sensitivities often dominate discussions around comedy, Nesteroff’s “Outrageous” and Fox’s “Comedy Book” offer a refreshing perspective. By exploring the history of comedy and its relationship with societal norms, these books remind us that the struggle between comedians and cultural sensitivities is not unique to the present. They highlight the resilience and adaptability of comedy throughout history, emphasizing its power to challenge, provoke, and unite. As we navigate the complexities of modern humor, these books serve as a reminder that comedy will continue to evolve, finding new ways to make us laugh and think, no matter the cultural climate.
Leave a Reply