The European Union becomes the first international body to introduce laws punishing wide-scale environmental destruction comparable to ecocide.
In a groundbreaking move, the European Union has approved an update to its environmental crime directive, making it the first international body to criminalize large-scale environmental damage akin to ecocide. The directive targets serious cases of ecosystem destruction, including habitat loss and illegal logging, and imposes stricter penalties. This decision marks a significant milestone in the fight against environmental crimes and could set a precedent for other regions. With the formal passing of the directive in the spring, member states will have two years to incorporate it into their national laws.
Defining Ecocide and its Growing Recognition
The EU’s update to the environmental crime directive does not explicitly mention the term “ecocide.” However, its preamble states its intention to criminalize actions comparable to ecocide, which cause widespread, irreversible, or long-lasting damage to significant ecosystems, habitats, or the quality of air, soil, or water. This aligns with the definition of ecocide developed by an international panel of legal experts in 2021. Originally intended for adoption by the International Criminal Court, this definition is now gaining traction in national-level legislation. Scotland, for instance, is currently considering the of the UK’s first ecocide law.
Scope and Coverage of the Revised EU Law
The revised EU law specifies various environmental activities that will be covered, including water abstraction, ship recycling and pollution, the and spread of invasive alien species, and ozone destruction. However, it does not address fishing, the export of toxic waste to developing countries, or carbon market fraud. Importantly, having a permit to carry out listed activities will not serve as an automatic excuse. Individuals and companies will be deemed to have committed a crime if the authorization was obtained fraudulently, through corruption, extortion, coercion, or if it breaches legal requirements.
Penalties and Enforcement Measures
The updated law introduces new penalties for environmental crimes. Individuals can face prison sentences, while companies may be excluded from accessing public funds. Member states will have the discretion to impose fines on companies based on a proportion of their turnover (up to 5% depending on the crime) or fixed amounts of up to €40 million (£35 million). EU Commissioner for Environment, Oceans, and Fisheries, Virginijus Sinkevičius, emphasized the seriousness and profitability of environmental crimes, citing the annual revenues from the illegal waste market in the EU, which range between €4 and €15 billion.
Implications and Global Impact
Marie Toussaint, a French lawyer and Member of the European Parliament leading the EU’s efforts to criminalize ecocide, hailed the decision as the end of impunity for environmental criminals and a potential catalyst for increased environmental litigation in Europe. The EU’s adoption of such ambitious legislation sets a precedent and provides support for environmental defenders in court. Jojo Mehta, co-founder and executive director of Stop Ecocide International, believes that with the growing momentum of the ecocide law initiative, it is only a matter of time before ecocide is recognized in criminal law at every level.
Conclusion: The European Union’s move to criminalize wide-scale environmental damage comparable to ecocide is a significant step forward in addressing the urgent need to protect ecosystems and combat environmental crimes. By introducing stricter penalties and creating a legal framework to hold individuals and companies accountable, the EU is sending a clear message that environmental destruction will no longer be tolerated. As other regions consider similar legislation, the global fight against ecocide gains momentum, offering hope for a more sustainable future.
Leave a Reply